Are we asking the wrong moral question about AI
We've spent the last year or so exploring AI and trying to find where it genuinely fits into our world.
Like most people, we've gone through the rollercoaster of emotions and the occasional amazement at what the technology can do, especially when you get the workflows right. The tools continue to improve at a remarkable pace, but the practical and moral questions surrounding them haven't become any simpler.
The moral side of AI is particularly difficult because there are no easy answers. Some people are uncomfortable with it. Some are enthusiastic about it. Most seem to sit somewhere in between, trying to work out where they stand.
And while a lot of those concerns are valid, one thing I keep coming back to is whether we are asking the wrong moral question.
Most of the debate centres around whether a brand should or should not use AI-generated images. But perhaps we should ask what happens when brands insist on traditional production without the budget to support it.
There's an old project management principle called the Iron Triangle. Every project is a balance between time, cost and quality. Improve one and the others inevitably come under pressure. You can have something quickly and cheaply, but quality suffers. You can have it quickly and beautifully, but it costs more. You can have it cheaply and beautifully, but you'll need more time.
The uncomfortable reality is that, for many brands today, those three sides of the triangle are not negotiable. The deadline is fixed. The budget is fixed. The expectation of quality is fixed. The campaign still needs to happen. The content volume is still expected. The variations still need producing.
But the triangle hasn't stopped existing. If time, cost and quality are all fixed, something else has to absorb the pressure.
Usually, it's the people.
The production is asked to do more for less. The producer is asked to stretch the impossible. The team is forced to bridge a gap that shouldn't really exist in the first place. The pressure simply gets pushed down the chain.
Which raises an interesting question.
If a brand cannot afford to execute something properly, is it more ethical to keep squeezing creative teams in order to deliver beyond what the budget justifies? Or is it more ethical to use AI for the parts of the process where it is good enough, and reserve traditional production for the moments that genuinely require human craft?
I don't think AI removes the moral question. I think it changes it.
Perhaps the question isn't whether it's inauthentic or immoral to use AI. Perhaps the question is whether we're willing to acknowledge the true cost of the work we're asking people to do.